Driftwood Victoria Breweries
Photo via driftwoodbeer.com

Justin McElroy, a CBC Journalist who you might remember from his viral competition to find the best Canadian TV show of all time, has made another set of rankings: The Best Breweries in Victoria.

Using a somewhat scientific method, McElroy and a select few tasters scored each brewery out of 50 points, with five distinct categories making up the total.

  • QUALITY — 20 points: how do the beers generally taste?
  • STANDOUT — 5 points: Do you have a favourite beer from the brewery?
  • DIVERSITY — 10 points: How many selections do they have in the tap room?
  • INNOVATION — 5 points: Do they put their own spin on beers?
  • EXPERIENCE — 10 points: How did you feel coming away from the tasting room?

Victoria Breweries

According to McElroy’s blog, “A score below 25 is bad. A score above 30 is fully acceptable. A score above 35 indicates real quality. A score above 40 is elite.”

As with any set of subjective rankings, McElroy’s have already generated some controversy. In fact, they’ve already drummed up dozens of not-so-supportive comments across social media and on Reddit:

Reddit Victoria Best Beer
Screenshot via Reddit

Also of note, three breweries in the area have been excluded: Sooke Brewing Company and Bad Dog Brewing for being too new, and Mayne Island Brewing, because of its limited opening hours.

Justin McElroy’s Rankings of Victoria Breweries

*To be clear, Victoria Buzz doesn’t endorse these rankings.

15 Vancouver Island Brewing 23.92
14 Twa Dogs 24.5
13 Canoe 25.25
12 Sooke Oceanside 27.5
11 Moon Under Water 28.3
10 Lighthouse 31.4
9 Spinnakers 32.58
8 Hoyne 32.81
7 Salt Spring Ales 33.13
6 Swans 33.5
5 Axe & Barrel 35.6
4 4 Mile 36.14
3 Phillips 36.75
2 Category 12 37.0
1 Driftwood 38.7


What do you think of this top 15? Let us know in the comments.

Stay in the loop! Get Victoria Buzz news, events and more directly to your inbox. Every day.